The Grand Intuitive.
Under review / Delphi, Indiana

The Delphi appeal

Updated September 24, 2026 · Source review, not a new allegation

Carroll County Courthouse in Delphi, Indiana
Carroll County Courthouse. A location photograph, not a photograph of the events. Photo: Nyttend / CC BY-SA 3.0.

The appeal asks whether decisions made at Richard Allen’s trial warrant a new trial. A question from a judge is not a ruling, and an appeal is not a finding that the conviction has been overturned.

What the record says

  1. February 2017Abigail Williams and Liberty German were killed near Delphi, Indiana.
  2. November 2024A jury convicted Richard Allen in their deaths.
  3. December 2024Allen received a 130-year sentence. His lawyers pursued an appeal.
  4. September 21, 2026An Indiana appeals panel heard arguments about trial evidence and exclusions. The panel had not ruled at the time of this update.

What is being argued

The defense argues that Allen’s confessions were unreliable during a period of mental decline and challenges exclusions of testimony and a police sketch. The state argues that the verdict should stand, pointing in part to Allen’s statements and the trial evidence. These are positions presented in court, not conclusions reached by this page.

What remains open

At this update, the appellate judges had not issued a decision. The next meaningful update is the court’s ruling. Until then, we should distinguish the questions asked at oral argument from what a written opinion eventually decides.

This page summarizes published reporting and identifies what is still unresolved. The Grand Intuitive’s own prediction or interpretation has not been supplied for this case.